By: Lily Rand
Photo Editor
Few brands have earned my loyalty the way Alani Nu has.
Since the company launched in 2018, Alani has been my go-to energy drink. As someone who does not drink coffee, an energy drink is often my caffeine fix throughout the day.
Alani consistently delivers flavors that are fun, creative and easy to enjoy.
My younger sister and I are such fans that trying new Alani flavors has become our thing. Whenever one of us finds a new release, we buy an extra can for the other. Sometimes we even wait until we are together to try it for the first time.
I have gone store-hopping in search of limited-edition flavors before, hoping to find them before they sell out.
That is why I was excited when I saw this year’s Winter Wonderland flavor. To be fair, the can itself almost sold me immediately.
One thing Alani consistently does well is packaging. The Winter Wonderland can is festive, colorful and everything a holiday release should be.
I have also always enjoyed that some Alani flavors are hinted at through the can design rather than clearly spelled out on the front. It makes trying a new flavor feel a little more exciting.
The reveal this year was Sugar Cookie.
The irony is that sugar cookies are my favorite cookies. If Alani Nu was ever going to create a flavor specifically for me, this should have been it.
It was not.
After only a few sips, I knew something was off. The flavor was so strong that it reminded me of opening every spice in a spice cabinet at once and taking a sip of the smell.
Cinnamon? Nutmeg? Ginger? Yes. All of them. At the same time.
I made it about halfway through the can before admitting defeat.
What made the experience even more disappointing is that unusual flavors can work.
In fact, my favorite Alani flavor is Sherbet Swirl. An orange sherbet-inspired energy drink sounds like it should taste terrible, yet it somehow captures the flavor perfectly.
Sugar Cookie was the opposite.
It felt like Alani was trying so hard to recreate a holiday dessert that it forgot one important detail; people still have to drink it.
The previous Winter Wonderland flavor, with its cranberry notes, was strong too, but it still felt refreshing. The new version replaces that balance with a flavor that, at least for me, was simply too much.
To Alani Nu’s credit, I appreciate the effort. Limited-edition flavors keep consumers interested, and not every release is going to be a winner for everyone. One disappointing flavor is not enough to make me stop buying Alani.
After years of releases I have enjoyed, this one simply joins the short list of flavors I would not purchase again.
Still, some holiday traditions are worth sticking to.
This year’s Winter Wonderland flavor proves that while holiday nostalgia can inspire great ideas, not all of those ideas need to become energy drinks.
Some things are better left on the dessert tray.